I think every professional copywriter with more than 6 years of agency experience probably has buried within him or her at least 2 novels, 5 nonfiction books, 8 screenplays, 48 letters to the editor, 142 short stories, 326 really angry letters to companies to let them know exactly what you think of their products and/or services and 1 really, really apologetic note to be left on someone’s car explaining how sorry you are you dinged their car and telling them where to contact you.
All of this said, I was not surprised when I heard that Sally Hogshead had turned her brilliant Creativity Magazine article into a book and I’m equally unsurprised that it’s a fabulous book with truths that can be applied beyond the advertising field.
Part of this lack of surprise arises from having heard her speak years ago at the Portfolio Center when I was a student there. She had won the One Show student competition just a few years before for her Virginia ad. She was brilliant, witty and inspiring.
Years later I saw her article in Creativity. It read like a brilliant cross between, Napoleon Hill, Ayn Rand and Alanis Morrisette, back in her Jagged Little Pill when she still had an attitude and something to shout about at the top of her lungs. The article was honest, clear, sharp and completely unforgiving.
Fortunately, unlike Alanis Morrisette, who seems to have left her clarity and attitude behind, perhaps in luggage lost somewhere in Calcutta, Sally Hogshead’s clarity and attitude are very much intact. In Radical Careering, she not only presents brutal truths, but she does it in a way that’s has special resonance for those in the advertising profession—namely product placement.
The book is sprinkled with eye-catching photos from Getty Images and more than enough website, executive and corporate plugs to plug all the leaks in the New Orleans’s levy system. That’s not a criticism, but a statement of fact and a subtle salute to a book that does more than talks about business savvy, it actually exhibits it.
Lest you think that this blog is nothing but a pure shot of 1000,000 watts of sunshine, there is one last thing that bugs me. That is it’s a true copywriter’s book and that’s both a positive and a negative.
As a positive, the burst-writing format of dividing the advice up to 100 easily digestible bits offers great copy examples. Put another way, since it is written in bursts about the length of a medium-to-long copy ad, there’s something to be learned from the style as well as the content.
As a negative, the burst-writing format results in a feeling of incompleteness. While the insights are sharp and clear, there’s a certain degree of hit-and-run delivery. You’re left wanting more… more specifics, more discussion and more penetration into the topics. I almost wish that instead of 100 Truths, the book had been 25 Truths with more discussion of each one. True, such a discussion would probably have limited the book’s market slightly by making it inevitably less general and more specific to advertising careers, but nonetheless I still wanted to hear more.
All that said, it is only one misgiving about an otherwise brilliant book. So the long and the short of it is, buy this book, read this book and, if you’re anything like me, hope that this book has a sister volume on the way that delivers the rest of the story. After all, something tells me the author has a lot more worth writing and worth reading.
10/18/05 Addendum:
Hey two nifty things I didn’t know just came to light.
First, according to my sources Sally Hogshead’s original Creativity article was at least partial inspired by a guest column she wrote for Talentzoo.com back in 2002.
Here’s the link: http://www.talentzoo.com/content/guestcolumnist/article/115.aspx
It’s an interesting read and true to the clarity and attitude of both her later article and her book.
Second, tomorrow, Talent Zoo is launching a podcast called “The Naked Career”. Sally is the host, and Lance Jensen, founder of Modernista! is her first guest. This will be the first show of Radio Talent Zoo, a network of podcasts concentrating on the communications industry.
To find out more about it visit talentzoo.com.
